A Homeowner’s Guide to Best Roofing Companies

Modern home with a new roof installed by one of the best roofing companies.

Your roof doesn’t work in a vacuum. It’s part of a complex system that includes your gutters, siding, and windows, all working together to protect your home from the elements. A problem in one area can easily affect another. That’s why the best roofing companies often have a deep understanding of the entire home exterior. They can spot potential issues with your siding or drainage that could impact your new roof, offering a more complete solution. This guide will help you find a contractor who sees the bigger picture, ensuring every component of your home’s protective shell functions perfectly together for years to come.

Key Takeaways

  • Prioritize Vetting Before Price: Your first step is to confirm any potential roofer is fully licensed and insured in New Jersey. A long history of positive reviews and a high rating with the Better Business Bureau are the best indicators of a trustworthy professional.
  • Look for Comprehensive Exterior Expertise: Your roof is part of a system that includes your siding, gutters, and windows. A contractor who understands how these elements work together can provide a more durable, cohesive solution and save you from coordinating multiple projects.
  • Invest in Long-Term Value, Not Just a Low Bid: The cheapest estimate often leads to costly repairs down the road. Focus on the overall value, which includes high-quality materials, expert installation, and strong warranties that protect your investment for years to come.

How to Choose the Best Roofing Company in New Jersey

Choosing a roofing company can feel like a huge task. Your roof is your home’s first line of defense, so you want to be sure you’re hiring a team that’s reliable, skilled, and trustworthy. In New Jersey, where we get everything from scorching sun to heavy snow, finding a contractor who understands our local climate is key. It’s not just about nailing down shingles; it’s about finding a partner who will protect your investment for years to come.

The good news is that with a little research, you can confidently find the right team for the job. It comes down to checking their credentials, listening to what other homeowners have to say, and making sure their process aligns with your needs. A great company will be transparent, communicative, and focused on providing a durable, high-quality solution for your home. Let’s walk through the essential steps to help you find a roofer you can count on.

Start with the Basics: Licensing, Insurance, and Estimates

Before you get into the details of materials or timelines, cover the non-negotiables. Any roofer you consider should be fully licensed to work in New Jersey and carry both liability insurance and workers’ compensation. This protects you from any liability in case of accidents on your property. Don’t just take their word for it—ask for proof. Next, get at least three written estimates. This isn’t about finding the cheapest price, but about comparing the scope of work, materials proposed, and overall professionalism. You can also check a company’s standing with the Better Business Bureau to see their rating and any customer complaints.

Look for Social Proof and Ask for Recommendations

Online reviews and word-of-mouth are your best friends here. Ask your neighbors, friends, or local community groups for recommendations. Hearing about a positive firsthand experience is incredibly valuable, especially from someone who has dealt with a company’s crew and responsiveness. When you look at online reviews, pay attention to consistency. A long history of five-star reviews is a strong indicator of quality work and customer satisfaction. Look for comments that mention good communication, clean job sites, and the ability to solve unexpected problems without a fuss. These details often tell you more than a simple star rating.

Evaluate Their Process and Communication

Pay close attention to how a company handles the initial consultation. Do they send an experienced roofer who gets on the roof to do a thorough inspection, or is it a salesperson focused only on closing a deal? A true professional will take the time to assess your specific situation and explain their recommendations clearly. Be wary of high-pressure sales tactics or unusually low bids, which could signal subpar materials or inexperienced labor. Clear, consistent communication is crucial. A company that is responsive and transparent from the start is more likely to keep you informed throughout the entire roofing project.

Consider the Bigger Picture: Services and Financing

Your roof is part of a larger system that protects your home. A company that offers more than just roofing—like siding, windows, and gutters—often has a better understanding of how all these exterior elements work together. This holistic expertise can prevent future problems and ensure everything functions as it should. Finally, don’t hesitate to ask about payment options. A quality roof is a significant investment, and many reputable companies offer financing plans to make the project more affordable. This flexibility shows that a company is established and committed to working with homeowners to meet their needs.

What Makes a Great Roofing Company Stand Out?

When you’re searching for a roofer, it can feel like every company website says the same thing. So, how do you tell the good from the truly great? The best roofing companies don’t just install roofs; they provide a seamless, professional experience from start to finish. They stand out by demonstrating a commitment to quality, accountability, and customer satisfaction that goes far beyond the basics. A top-tier company combines technical skill with a deep understanding of what homeowners need: reliability, transparency, and peace of mind. They’re not just contractors; they’re partners in protecting and improving your home. From the materials they choose to the warranties they offer, every detail reflects their dedication to excellence.

They Use High-Quality Materials and Modern Techniques

The difference between a roof that lasts a decade and one that lasts a lifetime often comes down to the quality of the materials and the skill of the installation. A standout company won’t cut corners. They use premium materials from trusted manufacturers and employ modern, proven techniques to ensure your roof is durable, resilient, and built to withstand New Jersey’s weather. Using advanced roofing techniques and quality materials is non-negotiable for them because they know it’s the foundation of a long-lasting, reliable roof. This commitment means you get a finished product that not only looks great but also provides superior protection for years to come.

They’re Licensed, Insured, and Accredited

Proper credentials are a baseline requirement, not a bonus. A great roofing company will always be fully licensed to operate in New Jersey, carry comprehensive liability insurance to protect your property, and have workers’ compensation for their crew. Beyond that, look for third-party validation like accreditation from the Better Business Bureau (BBB). As the BBB website explains, accredited businesses have been vetted and meet high standards of trust and transparency. These credentials show that a company is professional, accountable, and committed to operating ethically, giving you confidence that you’re in safe hands.

They Offer More Than Just Basic Roofing

A roof is part of a larger system that protects your home. The best companies understand this and offer a range of services to address your home’s entire exterior. They can spot potential issues with your gutters, siding, or chimney that might impact your new roof. Companies that excel in various exterior enhancements—from masonry work to window installation—can provide a more holistic solution for your home. This integrated approach ensures all components of your home’s exterior work together seamlessly, saving you the hassle of coordinating multiple contractors for one project.

They Provide Strong Warranties and Follow-Up Service

A warranty is a company’s promise to stand behind its work. A great roofer will offer robust warranties that cover both the materials and their own workmanship. For example, some top-tier contractors offer partnerships with manufacturers like GAF, which can include 50 years of coverage on the roofing system and 10 years on workmanship. This level of protection shows that the company is confident in the quality of their installation and is committed to your long-term satisfaction. It’s a clear sign that they plan to be around to honor their promises and address any issues that might arise down the road.

They Have Years of Local Experience

There’s no substitute for local expertise. A company with decades of experience working in New Jersey understands the specific challenges our climate presents, from humid summers to icy winters. They know the local building codes inside and out and have established relationships with the best local suppliers. A long-standing presence in the community, like a company that has been in business for over 40 years, is a strong indicator of stability and reliability. They have a proven track record and a reputation to uphold, which means they’re invested in doing the job right for their neighbors.

What Should You Look for When Choosing a Roofer?

Finding the right roofer can feel like a huge task, but knowing what to look for makes all the difference. A great roofing company does more than just install shingles; they provide peace of mind. When you’re vetting potential contractors, focus on a few key areas. These details will help you separate the true professionals from the rest and ensure you’re making a smart investment in your home’s protection and value.

Verify Their Credentials and Get Multiple Written Estimates

Before you even think about pricing, do a background check. A reputable roofer will be fully licensed and insured in New Jersey—this is non-negotiable. Insurance protects you from liability if a worker gets injured on your property. You can also check their standing with organizations like the Better Business Bureau. The BBB directory is a great place to find accredited businesses and read customer reviews. Always get at least three written estimates. This isn’t just about comparing prices; it’s about seeing how different companies detail the scope of work, materials, and timeline. A detailed, professional estimate is a good sign of a thorough contractor.

Ask if They Use Employees or Subcontractors

This is a question many homeowners forget to ask, but it’s incredibly important. Find out if the company uses its own dedicated team or if they hire subcontractors for the job. A company with its own employees often has more control over training, quality, and scheduling. While many great roofers use trusted subcontractors, it’s good to know who will actually be on your property. If they do use subcontractors, ask how long they’ve worked with them and if they are also insured. This helps ensure accountability and a consistent standard of work from the team that shows up at your door.

Evaluate Their Communication and Assessment Process

Pay close attention to how a potential roofer communicates from the very first call. Are they responsive, clear, and willing to answer all your questions? A professional contractor should walk you through their assessment process, explaining what they’re looking for and why. They should provide a clear, detailed explanation of the proposed work, the roofing materials they plan to use, and the expected timeline. Vague answers or pressure to sign a contract immediately are red flags. You want a partner who is transparent and keeps you informed every step of the way, ensuring there are no surprises.

Check Their Emergency Services and Project Timelines

New Jersey weather can be unpredictable, and a storm can cause sudden damage. Ask potential roofers if they offer emergency services and what their response time looks like. Knowing you have a reliable contractor to call in a crisis is invaluable. Beyond emergencies, a good roofer should provide a realistic and firm project timeline. Ask for a clear start and end date, and find out how they handle potential delays, like bad weather. A contractor who can’t give you a straight answer about their schedule might be overbooked or poorly organized, which could lead to your project dragging on for weeks.

Avoid the Lowest Bid (And Why Price Isn’t Everything)

It’s tempting to jump on the lowest estimate, but a price that seems too good to be true usually is. An unusually low bid can be a sign of cutting corners, whether it’s with subpar materials, unskilled labor, or inadequate insurance. Instead of focusing solely on the price tag, consider the overall value. A slightly higher estimate might include superior materials, a more experienced crew, and a stronger warranty—all things that save you money and headaches in the long run. Think of your roof as a long-term investment in your home’s safety. A quality job from a reputable company is always worth it.

How Can You Use Customer Reviews to Find the Best Roofer?

When you’re looking for a roofer, online reviews are your best friend. They offer a real-world look into a company’s performance, straight from other homeowners. But reading reviews is more than just looking for a high star rating; it’s about learning to read between the lines. A little bit of detective work can help you understand a company’s reliability, quality of work, and how they treat their customers when things don’t go perfectly. By knowing what to look for—and what to watch out for—you can use reviews to confidently choose a roofing contractor who will protect your home for years to come.

The Importance of Consistent Five-Star Reviews

A few great reviews are nice, but a long history of them is even better. Consistency is key because it shows a company doesn’t just have a few good days—it has a solid track record of quality work and happy customers. When you see dozens or even hundreds of positive reviews spanning several years, it’s a strong signal that the company is stable, professional, and committed to customer satisfaction. The Better Business Bureau (BBB) recommends checking ratings and customer feedback to get a clear picture of a contractor’s reputation. A pattern of five-star ratings suggests you can expect the same level of service for your own project.

How to Spot Authentic Customer Feedback

Authentic reviews are detailed and specific. Instead of just saying “great job,” a real customer will often mention the specific problem they had, the crew members they worked with, and how the company handled the process from start to finish. Look for reviews across multiple platforms like Google, Yelp, and industry-specific sites. This gives you a more balanced view than relying on a single source. Genuine feedback often includes both pros and cons, which can feel more trustworthy than a review that sounds like a perfect advertisement. Pay attention to reviews that describe the company’s communication, cleanliness, and how they handled unexpected issues.

Watch Out for These Red Flags in Online Reviews

While you’re looking for positive signs, keep an eye out for red flags. Be cautious if a company’s reviews are all posted within a very short time frame, as this could indicate they aren’t genuine. Another warning sign is a contractor who sends a salesperson to provide a quote instead of an actual roofer who can properly assess your needs. According to homeowners on forums like Reddit, you should also be wary if the person who inspects your roof doesn’t put their full name on the contract. And while a low price is tempting, an estimate that is significantly lower than all the others could signal cut corners or hidden costs down the line.

What Do BBB Ratings and Accreditations Really Mean?

The Better Business Bureau provides another layer of insight that goes beyond customer reviews. BBB ratings, which range from A+ to F, reflect how well a business interacts with its customers, including its responsiveness to complaints. A company that is “BBB Accredited” has gone a step further by committing to meet and uphold the BBB’s standards for trust and integrity. Seeing that accreditation means the business has been vetted, which can give you extra peace of mind. It’s a valuable tool for confirming that a company not only does good work but also operates ethically and transparently.

What Services Do Top Roofing Companies Offer?

When you think about a roofing company, you probably picture a team replacing shingles. While that’s a core part of the job, the best companies offer a much wider range of services to protect and improve your entire home. They understand that your roof is just one part of a larger system that keeps your house safe, dry, and looking its best. A truly great contractor doesn’t just see a roof; they see the entire exterior envelope of your home. This means they’re equipped to handle everything from the initial installation and routine repairs to offering advanced, energy-efficient materials that can lower your utility bills.

Furthermore, top companies recognize that a roof doesn’t exist in isolation. It works in tandem with your gutters, siding, and even your windows to protect your home from the elements. That’s why they often provide these services as well, acting as a comprehensive partner for all your exterior needs. This holistic approach not only ensures quality and consistency across all your projects but also makes your life significantly easier. Instead of vetting and managing multiple contractors, you have a single, trusted point of contact. This integrated service model is a hallmark of a company that is invested in the long-term health and beauty of your home.

Residential and Commercial Roof Installation and Repair

At its heart, a great roofing company excels at its primary function: installing and repairing roofs. This applies to both residential homes and commercial properties, each with its own unique requirements. Whether you have a small leak that needs a quick patch or require a full roof replacement, a reputable contractor has the skills to handle the job. Using advanced techniques and quality materials, they ensure your new roof is durable and built to last. They should be proficient with a variety of materials, from traditional asphalt shingles to modern metal or flat roofing systems, and be able to guide you toward the best choice for your property’s style and budget.

Energy-Efficient and Eco-Friendly Roofing Options

Today’s roofing materials can do more than just keep the rain out; they can also help you save money and reduce your carbon footprint. Leading roofing companies offer energy-efficient options designed to reflect more sunlight and absorb less heat, which can lower your cooling costs during hot New Jersey summers. These “cool roofs” are a smart investment in your home’s long-term efficiency. You can also find options made from sustainable or recycled materials. Choosing the right roofing company is important for a quality roof that lasts, and that includes having access to modern, eco-friendly solutions that benefit both your wallet and the environment.

More Than Roofing: Gutters, Siding, and Exterior Work

The best roofing contractors know that a healthy roof is supported by other key components of your home’s exterior. That’s why they often provide a full suite of services. Beyond their expertise in roofing, skilled professionals can handle various exterior enhancements, including gutter installation, siding replacement, and window upgrades. This integrated approach is a huge advantage for homeowners. Instead of juggling multiple contractors, you have one team that understands how all the pieces of your home’s exterior work together. This ensures a cohesive look, consistent quality, and a much smoother renovation process from start to finish.

Roofs Built to Handle New Jersey Weather

New Jersey weather is no joke. From heavy snow and ice in the winter to humid summers and coastal storms, your roof takes a beating all year long. A top local roofing company understands these specific challenges and provides solutions designed to withstand them. This means using materials and installation techniques that prevent ice dams, resist high winds, and manage heavy rainfall effectively. They can also address weather-related damage to other parts of your home, like performing chimney resurfacing or masonry repairs. This local expertise is invaluable for ensuring your roof provides reliable, long-lasting protection against whatever Mother Nature throws its way.

How Can You Get a Quality Roof Without Overspending?

A new roof is one of the most significant investments you’ll make in your home. It’s completely normal to want the best possible quality without draining your savings. The good news is that with a little planning, you can absolutely achieve both. It’s not about finding the cheapest option, but about making a smart, informed decision that protects your home and your wallet for years to come. Here’s how to approach it.

Start with a Free, No-Obligation Estimate

Your first step should always be to schedule a free, no-obligation estimate with a few reputable local roofers. This isn’t just about collecting price quotes; it’s an opportunity to get a professional diagnosis of your roof’s current condition. A thorough contractor will inspect for damage, assess the remaining lifespan, and explain whether a simple repair or a full replacement is necessary. Getting several detailed, written estimates helps you understand the fair market rate for your project and compare what each company includes in their price, so you can request a quote with confidence.

Clarify Insurance Coverage and Out-of-Pocket Costs

If you suspect your roof damage is covered by your homeowner’s policy—perhaps from a storm or a fallen tree—contact your insurance agent right away. Before you sign any contracts, you need to understand your policy inside and out. Ask your agent about your deductible, what specific types of damage are covered, and what documentation you’ll need to file a claim. Understanding the homeowners insurance claims process ahead of time prevents surprise out-of-pocket costs and ensures you get the full benefit you’re entitled to, making the entire project much more manageable.

Ask About Financing and Flexible Payment Plans

Don’t let the upfront cost of a quality roof keep you from moving forward with a necessary project. Many established roofing companies understand that a new roof is a major expense and offer financing options to make it more affordable. When you’re getting estimates, be sure to ask about flexible payment plans. Some contractors partner with lenders to offer plans with low or even 0% interest for a promotional period. This allows you to break down the total cost into predictable monthly payments, so you can get the safe, reliable roof you need now without financial strain.

Focus on Long-Term Value, Not Just the Initial Price

It can be tempting to jump on the lowest bid, but that’s often a recipe for future headaches and expenses. The initial price tag doesn’t tell the whole story. A cheap roof might be installed with inferior materials or by an inexperienced crew, leading to premature leaks, repairs, and a shorter lifespan. Instead, think about the long-term value. Investing in a quality roofing system from a trusted contractor means you’re paying for durable materials, expert installation, and a solid warranty. This approach saves you money over time by preventing costly repairs and giving you peace of mind.

Who Should You Trust With Your Next Roofing Project?

When it’s time to hire a professional, you’ll find yourself facing a big decision: should you go with a large national chain or a dedicated local expert? Both have their advantages, and the right choice often comes down to your specific needs, the scope of your project, and the level of personalized service you’re looking for. A new roof is a major investment in your home’s safety and value, so it’s worth taking the time to understand who you’re hiring. Let’s walk through the different types of companies you’ll encounter and what each one brings to the table.

Considering a National Roofing Company

National roofing companies are the big names you might see advertised across the country. Their main advantage is often their vast resources and standardized processes. They typically have large crews, extensive equipment, and established supply chains, which can sometimes lead to faster project start times. Because of their scale, they may also offer branded financing options or proprietary materials. However, working with a national chain can sometimes feel impersonal. You might deal with a call center or a rotating cast of project managers, and the crew that shows up at your door may not be local or have deep knowledge of New Jersey-specific building codes and weather challenges.

The Benefits of a Regional, Local Expert

A local roofing expert offers a completely different experience. These companies live and work in the same communities they serve, so their reputation is everything. They have a deep understanding of local weather patterns—from humid summers to icy winters—and know which materials and techniques work best for New Jersey homes. You’re more likely to work directly with the owner or a dedicated project manager who knows your name and is invested in your satisfaction. You can also easily check their local reputation through customer reviews and ratings on trusted sites. A local company has a vested interest in doing great work because their next job often comes from a neighbor’s referral.

Finding a Specialist for Eco-Friendly Roofing

If sustainability is a priority for you, you might look for a company that specializes in eco-friendly roofing. These contractors are knowledgeable about materials like recycled shingles, cool roofs that reflect sunlight to reduce cooling costs, and systems designed to support solar panels. They can also advise on proper ventilation and insulation to make your entire home more energy-efficient. While not every roofer is an eco-specialist, a quality contractor should be able to discuss these options with you. A company’s commitment to reducing, reusing, and recycling old roofing materials is also a great sign that they care about their environmental impact.

Why New Jersey Homeowners Choose Garden State Brickface and Siding

For homeowners in New Jersey, Garden State Brickface and Siding offers the best of both worlds. We combine the professionalism and high-quality materials of a large company with the personalized service and local expertise of a neighborhood contractor. We understand that a roof is just one part of your home’s exterior, which is why we also specialize in siding, windows, and masonry. Our team uses advanced techniques and top-tier materials to ensure every roof we install is durable, resilient, and built to protect your home for years to come. With deep roots in the community and over 200 five-star reviews, we’ve built our reputation on trust and exceptional results.

Related Articles

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the absolute must-haves I should look for in a roofing company? Before you get into the details of shingle colors or project timelines, make sure any company you consider has its fundamentals in order. They must be fully licensed to work in New Jersey and carry both liability insurance and workers’ compensation. This is non-negotiable, as it protects you from any financial responsibility for accidents. Beyond that, look for a company with a long-standing, positive reputation in your local community and a solid history of positive customer reviews.

Why shouldn’t I just go with the cheapest estimate? It’s always tempting to choose the lowest price, but a bid that’s significantly cheaper than the others is often a red flag. This could mean the company is using lower-quality materials, hiring less experienced labor, or isn’t properly insured. A quality roof is a long-term investment in your home’s safety. Focusing on the best overall value—which includes durable materials, skilled installation, and a strong warranty—will save you from costly repairs and headaches down the road.

How important is it to hire a local New Jersey roofer? Hiring a local expert is incredibly important. A company with years of experience in New Jersey understands our specific climate challenges, from heavy snow and ice dams in the winter to high humidity in the summer. They know which materials and installation techniques hold up best against our weather and are familiar with local building codes. A local company also has a reputation to maintain right here in your community, which means they are more invested in your satisfaction.

My home needs more than just a new roof. Should I hire separate contractors for siding or gutters? You can, but it’s often much smoother to work with one company that handles all exterior services. A contractor who specializes in roofing, siding, and gutters understands how these systems work together to protect your home. This integrated approach ensures a cohesive look and prevents issues that can arise from uncoordinated work. It also simplifies the process for you, as you only have to manage one team and one point of contact.

What’s the difference between a workmanship warranty and a material warranty? This is a great question because the distinction is crucial. A material warranty covers the physical products—the shingles, underlayment, etc.—against manufacturing defects, and it’s provided by the product manufacturer. A workmanship warranty is provided by the roofing contractor and covers the installation itself. It’s the roofer’s promise to stand behind the quality of their work. A reputable company will offer a strong warranty on both, giving you complete peace of mind.